Scotopic sensitivity was compared in young and older adults in good eye health after individualized correction for age-related changes in lens density and control of pupil diameter. Unlike earlier studies on this topic, fundus photography and a grading scale were used to characterize macular health in the older sample. Twenty-four young adults (mean age 27) and 25 older adults (mean age 70 years) underwent scotopic sensitivity testing after 30 min of dark adaptation. Light sensitivity for a 450 nm target was measured at 4, 7, 32, and 38 degrees both nasally and temporally along the horizontal meridian. Lens density was estimated using Sample's method. On average, older adults exhibited a 0.5 log unit decrease in sensitivity even with lens density taken into account, which did not vary with target eccentricity or nasal/temporal hemifield. Although 60% of older subjects exhibited fundoscopic signs of early age-related maculopathy (ARM), even those free from these signs demonstrated a half log unit sensitivity loss, suggesting that this impairment may represent a biological aging process. We found no psychophysical evidence that scotopic sensitivity loss in older adults with relatively good retinal health is accentuated in the peri-macula, even though anatomical studies on donor retinas from older adults have indicated that this area has heightened rod loss.