Immunocytochemistry versus nucleic acid amplification in fine needle aspirates and tissues of extrapulmonary tuberculosis. 2012

Madhu Mati Goel, and Puja Budhwar, and Amita Jain
Department of Pathology, Chhatrapati Shahuji Maharaj Medical University (erstwhile King George's Medical University) Lucknow, India.

BACKGROUND Immunocytochemistry (ICC) is an established routine diagnostic adjunct to cytology and histology for tumor diagnosis but has received little attention for diagnosis of tuberculosis. OBJECTIVE To have an objective method of direct visualization of mycobacteria or their products in clinical extrapulmonary tuberculosis (EPTB) specimens, immunocytochemical localization of M. tuberculosis antigen by staining with species specific monoclonal antibody to 38-kDa antigen of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex. METHODS Immunostaining with specific monoclonal antibody to 38-kDa antigen of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex was done in fresh and archival fine needle aspirates and tissue granulomata of 302 cases of extrapulmonary tuberculosis and was compared with the molecular diagnostic i.e., nucleic amplification and conventional [Cytomorphology, Ziehl Neelsen (ZN) staining and culture] tests and 386 controls. RESULTS Diagnostic indices by Bayesian analysis for all types of archival and fresh material varied from 64 to 76% in nucleic acid amplification (NAA) and 96 to 98% in ICC. There was no significant difference in the diagnostic indices of ZN staining and/ or ICC in fresh or archival material whereas the sensitivity of NAA differed significantly in fresh versus archival material both in cytology (71.4% vs 52.1%) and histology (51.1% vs 38.8%). ICC can be easily used on archival smears and formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue sections with almost equal sensitivity and specificity as with fresh material, in contrast to NAA which showed significant difference in test results on archival and fresh material. CONCLUSIONS Low detection sensitivity of MTB DNA in archival material from known tuberculous cases showed the limitation of in-house NAA-based molecular diagnosis. ICC was found to be sensitive, specific and a better technique than NAA and can be used as an adjunct to conventional morphology and ZN staining for the diagnosis of EPTB in tissue granulomas.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Madhu Mati Goel, and Puja Budhwar, and Amita Jain
January 1990, Acta cytologica,
Madhu Mati Goel, and Puja Budhwar, and Amita Jain
January 1990, Acta cytologica,
Madhu Mati Goel, and Puja Budhwar, and Amita Jain
August 1998, The British journal of oral & maxillofacial surgery,
Madhu Mati Goel, and Puja Budhwar, and Amita Jain
January 1989, Acta cytologica,
Madhu Mati Goel, and Puja Budhwar, and Amita Jain
January 2011, Nigerian journal of clinical practice,
Madhu Mati Goel, and Puja Budhwar, and Amita Jain
June 2023, The Journal of the Association of Physicians of India,
Madhu Mati Goel, and Puja Budhwar, and Amita Jain
March 1991, The Australian and New Zealand journal of surgery,
Madhu Mati Goel, and Puja Budhwar, and Amita Jain
December 2014, Cancer cytopathology,
Madhu Mati Goel, and Puja Budhwar, and Amita Jain
February 2013, Cytopathology : official journal of the British Society for Clinical Cytology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!